In a momentous evening in Philadelphia, Penn State’s wrestling star Carter Starocci etched his name into the history books. Winning his fifth NCAA title, Starocci became the first wrestler ever to reach this pinnacle. His victory over Northern Iowa’s Parker Keckeisen in the 184-pound championship with a score of 4-1 was not just a win but a historic achievement. However, his triumph was shadowed by concerns over the scheduling of his final match.
A Historic Victory with a Hint of Controversy
The decision to schedule the 184-pound final as the first match of the evening was met with criticism from Starocci. The Erie, Pa., native expressed his bemusement with the decision, questioning the rationale behind ESPN’s scheduling. “I’m not sure why ESPN elected for the 184-pound match to be the first one,” Starocci remarked. He highlighted the significance of his match, being a potential duel for the Hodge Trophy—a wrestling equivalent of football’s Heisman Trophy—against the reigning champion.
Starocci’s frustration stemmed from what he perceived as a broader issue with how wrestling is presented and perceived in mainstream media. “It just kind of makes me laugh and giggle, just because, some of the rules that wrestling has in place and things like that, just, it’s no surprise on why wrestling isn’t mainstream,” he explained. His comments not only reflect his personal views but also challenge the media and stakeholders to rethink how the sport is marketed and broadcasted.
The Bout Order Controversy: A Media and Fan Backlash
The rearrangement of the traditional bout order, which typically follows a 125-285 pound format, to highlight particular matches has sparked debates. This year, the NCAA and ESPN opted to spotlight the Starocci-Keckeisen match by scheduling it first, followed by the remaining matches, culminating with Gable Steveson’s final college match in the 285-pound category. This decision was reportedly made by ESPN to “start something good,” according to NCAA officials. Yet, this move was met with disapproval on social media, reflecting a disconnect between fan expectations and broadcaster strategy.
Carter Starocci on His Legacy and Future
Beyond the controversy, Starocci shared his reflections on his remarkable achievement and his aspirations. “It means a lot to me. I never want to downplay the moment. It’s always cool,” he stated, emphasizing the importance of character and personal development over titles. His coach, Cael Sanderson, instills in the team that achievements are merely stepping stones for larger life lessons.
When asked about his legacy at Penn State, Starocci expressed a desire to be remembered as a relentless leader. “I think just a guy that just always led by example, always showed up, and it’s no matter the day, if you’re hurt, injured, sad, no matter what, always put your best foot forward,” he said. His ethos is to push for continual improvement and to inspire the next generation to uphold the Penn State wrestling dynasty.
As Carter Starocci celebrates his unprecedented fifth NCAA title, his critiques offer a moment for reflection on how wrestling is showcased in the media. His call for a strategic overhaul in how wrestling matches are scheduled and broadcasted could be pivotal in enhancing the sport’s mainstream appeal. This historic evening not only celebrates a personal victory for Starocci but also poses significant questions about the future presentation of wrestling on major sports platforms.